Sun, 6 September 2009 In this week’s episode of the Gamma Quadrant, we actually enjoy a B storyline with Jake and Nog! We don’t enjoy grumpy, unlikable old men, and in this special case, we endorse kidnapping and arson. Comments[7] |
Hi Gamma Group,
Just a short thank you note. I heard about your 'cast from Starship Sofa. Great idea. I've been watching each episode and then listening to your reviews. I'm now up to speed.
Thank you!
Tom
Going Linux Podcast
Just a short thank you note. I heard about your 'cast from Starship Sofa. Great idea. I've been watching each episode and then listening to your reviews. I'm now up to speed.
Thank you!
Tom
Going Linux Podcast
posted by: Tom Chaudoir on Mon, 9/7 07:45 PM EDT
Another good one! Sure...the Jake-Nog Consortium storyline was good...but only to be enjoyed then moved on with. The other storyline was far more interesting. Far being it from me to second-guess the writer, but I thought Mullibok was perfectly played. Brian Keith is excellent...as usual. I liken the character to a kindlier version of the older gentleman who refused to leave the Mount St. Helens area in the face of imminent eruption. (He was later killed by the eruption.) Mullibok saw his share of pain, suffering, and authoritarian abuses...and wanted to be left alone. But he still seemed to understand his buried sense of futility and need to connect with other people. Kira finding an even meaner curmudgeon on the moon would have made her forced-evacuation-or-no moral dilemna a no-brainer. Of real impact to me was Sisko's statement to Kira..."you're on the other side now." It's one thing to fight (or fight for the "little guy" who's suffering) authoritarian abuses...and yet another when you are now the authoritarian...especially when the authority you represent is doing something "good" for the "benefit of all." Kira's dilemna gave me pause to reflect the entanglements of "justice", "fairness", "rights", and "progress"...entanglements worth perpetually reflecting.
Oh AB, you are on my wavelength today! This is a huge Kira growing episode. She comes to several realization "ah-ha" moments. First, that she likes and even identifies with Mullibok. He is a reflection of her own inner fighter. Second, she has a job to perform for the benefit of the greater good. Third, that her role in this will not be one of any gratification, but something she must come to terms with and then impliment, despite her personal feelings. She must become the tool of the provisional government. What a psychological transformation from where she was in episode one!! I personally find Kira's story, on of the most compelling on DS9. I am glad that Val is coming around on Kira, and I'd not be surprised if she is a favortie of hers by the end. This show is all about accepting people, giving them the room to grow, and then watching it all work itself out. I love it, and will continue to think it the finest Trek series for a long time I am sure.
posted by: Thot Pran on Mon, 9/7 11:22 PM EDT
I actually decided to rewatch this episode before listening to this episode, since the podcast is weekly I think I can squeeze in time to watch along with the show.
I hated Mullibok too, but I liked the Kira development too. I think the bit when it hits best is when Sisko echoes the analogy of Kira being in the same position when she was in the resistance and the look on her face when she's processing it all.
I enjoyed the Nojay B-plot too, and hadn't noticed that Nog probably screwed over his dad too, that's a nice catch.
As for the Mullibok strangling moment it was weird because of how his eyes just BUG OUT. It made me think that he was like a sleeper agent post-hypnotic suggestion super soldier who freaks out on people when triggered. It was funny to hear everyone's reaction to that.
I hated Mullibok too, but I liked the Kira development too. I think the bit when it hits best is when Sisko echoes the analogy of Kira being in the same position when she was in the resistance and the look on her face when she's processing it all.
I enjoyed the Nojay B-plot too, and hadn't noticed that Nog probably screwed over his dad too, that's a nice catch.
As for the Mullibok strangling moment it was weird because of how his eyes just BUG OUT. It made me think that he was like a sleeper agent post-hypnotic suggestion super soldier who freaks out on people when triggered. It was funny to hear everyone's reaction to that.
posted by: Derek on Tue, 9/8 02:09 PM EDT
Yeh Derek...I can see a "super soldier" connection. Maybe a bit of lashing out...maybe "suicide by cop"...maybe all three. I see Mullibok as a fairly righteous guy with a gripe...whose prized control of himself and his world is slipping away. To face this with a (albeit skewed) sense of humor and solemn defiance allowed me to empathize with him (and, thus, Kira's dilemma) all the more.
Hello Gamma Quadrant!
Thanks for another fabulous episode. I enjoy hearing your opinions and fun facts about a new ds9 episode each week. I received your name from listening to Trekcast and I've been hooked ever since. Your shows just get better each time!
I look forward to the next installment. Thanks for keeping ds9 alive!
AML
Thanks for another fabulous episode. I enjoy hearing your opinions and fun facts about a new ds9 episode each week. I received your name from listening to Trekcast and I've been hooked ever since. Your shows just get better each time!
I look forward to the next installment. Thanks for keeping ds9 alive!
AML
Haha I love this sub-plot! I love it so much I don't mind they reuse it a couple more times. As for the rest of the episode, just wonderful. Kira gets some great episodes, especially early on. The writers really utilize the conflicting vulnerability of having to rebuild a life from nothing and her very hard fighter instincts.
Post your comment:
